Skip to content

Gridsmith

Editing

Manuscript Assessment

You want to know whether it is any good before spending anything else on it.

A written assessment of a complete manuscript: what works, what does not, what it would take to fix, and whether that is worth doing.

The recommendation is honest, and it includes the possibility that the answer is not yet, or not with us. An assessment that always recommends the next paid stage is worthless as an assessment.

What this covers

  • Manuscript assessment

What you get

Written assessment
Included
Structure, voice, pacing, argument and audience fit.
Structural recommendations
Included
What to change, in priority order.
A clear recommendation
Included
Including "not yet", or that another route suits it better.

What you do not get

Line editing
Not included
An assessment reads the whole and does not edit the sentences. That is copy editing.

How it runs, and what it asks of you

The six stages are the same on every Gridsmith engagement. Where your own time is listed, it is the part of a project that is worth knowing before it starts.

Consultation
We read what exists — a manuscript, a draft, notes, or nothing yet — and establish what the piece is for and who reads it.
Planning & Scope
Scope is written as length, structure, the number of review rounds and what each round covers.
Approval & Start
Work starts once scope is agreed. Research material, interviews and source documents are arranged at this point.
Design, Development & Updates
Drafts are delivered in agreed stages so the direction can be corrected early rather than at the end.
Delivery
Final text or production files in the agreed formats. Authorship and copyright arrangements are whatever the written agreement sets out.
Support (if applicable)
Further rounds, later editions and ongoing programmes can be scoped as further work or as an ongoing engagement, whichever suits how you work.